Fill a chilled tall glass with some of the ice to chill and set aside. Keep the soda water cold.
Add Jamaican rum, lime juice, demerara syrup, and Angostura bitters to a cocktail shaker. Add about 1 cup of the ice. Shake hard until the shaker is frosty, 10–12 seconds.
Discard the ice from the glass and fill it with fresh ice. Strain the drink into the glass. Top with the chilled soda water and give a brief stir to combine.
Slap the mint sprig once to release aroma and add it to the drink; grate a light dusting of nutmeg over the top. Serve immediately.