Suggestions

Knuckle Sandwich

2 hours 15 minutes6 sandwiches

contains meat

Knuckle sandwich

Recipe Shopping List

Knuckle Sandwich · 6 sandwiches

Swipe toward the center or use the arrows to update your pantry. Tap an item to edit its name and amount.

Need to buy

Checking pantry…

    Already have

    Checking pantry…

      Checking your pantry…

      Rating
      Not yet rated
      Review

      Ingredients

      • 2 1/2 pounds beef knuckle roast (sirloin tip roast) – patted dry
      • 2¾ tsp kosher salt (13g)total — 3 portions; expand for amounts and preparation
        • 2 tsp kosher salt – for roast (9.6g)
        • 1/2 tsp kosher salt – for onions (2.4g)
        • 1/4 tsp kosher salt – for sauce (1.2g)
      • 1¼ tsp black peppertotal — 2 portions; expand for amounts and preparation
        • 1 tsp black pepper – for roast
        • 1/4 tsp black pepper – for sauce
      • 2 cloves garlic – finely grated, for roast
      • 2 tsp Dijon mustard – for roast
      • ¼ cup olive oiltotal — 3 portions; expand for amounts and preparation
        • 2 tbsp olive oil – for roast
        • 1 tbsp olive oil – for onions
        • 1 tbsp olive oil – for toasting rolls
      • 1 tsp rosemary – finely chopped, for roast
      • 1 tsp thyme leaves – finely chopped, for roast
      • 24 ounces yellow onions – thinly sliced (~5 medium yellow onions)
      • 1 1/2 tbsp unsalted butter – for onions
      • 2 tbsp water – for deglazing onions
      • 1 tsp apple cider vinegar – for onions
      • 1/2 cup mayonnaise – for sauce
      • 2 tbsp prepared horseradish – for sauce
      • 1 tbsp lemon juice – for sauce
      • 2 cups arugula – for assembly
      • 6 each sandwich rolls – split

      Instructions

      A knuckle sandwich, in this culinary sense, is a robust roast beef sandwich built from the beef knuckle (sirloin tip) roast, layered onto crisp-toasted rolls with sweet caramelized onions, a sharp horseradish sauce, and peppery greens. The meat is cooked gently for a rosy interior, then sliced very thin so it stays tender and juicy. The result balances rich beef, creamy heat, gentle sweetness, and a fresh bite for a satisfying, two-handed meal.

      The name plays on American slang, but the sandwich has real butcher’s roots: the beef “knuckle” is a classic deli roasting cut prized for lean, beefy flavor when sliced thin. As delis and home cooks popularized sirloin tip roasts, pairings like horseradish, onions, and crusty bread followed naturally. Today, this interpretation turns a joke into a specialty sandwich with clear lineage to American roast beef traditions.

      Create your own version with changes to the ingredients, amounts, or instructions.